2003issue C091-17
Construct a volatility-adjusted on-balance volume filter before confirming a breakout
Treat signed volume as a construction problem. First decide how much of a bar counts as buying or selling, then ask whether that signed volume confirms a breakout. Typical price, a two-part volatility cutoff, and a money-flow component turn on-balance volume into a bounded oscillator that can reject a breakout hypothesis.
- Typical price, the average of high, low, and close, is the reference for locating the close in the bar and for measuring change from the prior bar.
- Volume is tagged +1 or -1 only when the money-flow component clears a volatility cutoff scaled by close. Otherwise the bar contributes zero signed volume.
- The finite volume element is one hundred times the sample-window sum of signed volume, divided by average volume times the same sample length, so the reading is a bounded oscillator rather than an unbounded total.
- A breakout stays a hypothesis until the same signing function, and a constructed price-path test, can reject it.
Start with enough movement
Editorial: read this as a construction checklist, not as a finished indicator. First decide how much of a bar's range is enough movement to count as buying or selling. Only then ask whether the signed volume is confirming a breakout.
On-balance volume adds or subtracts a bar's volume according to whether that bar is classified as buying or selling pressure. Volume-price analysis is the classification step. A bar's location in its range, and the size of that range relative to recent volatility, decide whether volume is assigned, ignored, or treated as noise.
Typical price and two volatilities
A bar's typical price is the average of high, low, and close. That value is the reference both for locating the close in the bar and for measuring change from the prior bar.
Intra-bar volatility is the sample standard deviation of the log high-minus-log low range. Inter-bar volatility is the sample standard deviation of the log change in typical price.
Sign volume only after the cutoff
The volatility cutoff that decides whether a bar's volume is signed is a weighted sum of those two volatility measures, using separate intra-bar and inter-bar coefficients. That cutoff is then compared with the money-flow component scaled by close.
The money-flow component adds the close's distance from the bar midpoint to the change in typical price. Only when that score exceeds the cutoff times close is volume tagged +1. Only when it falls below the negative of that product is volume tagged -1. Otherwise the bar contributes zero signed volume.
A bounded oscillator, not a running total
The finite volume element reading is one hundred times the sample-window sum of signed volume, divided by average volume times the same sample length. The result is a bounded, percentage-like oscillator rather than an unbounded cumulative total.
On bars classified as less than daily, the construction substitutes tick count for reported volume so the same signed-volume formula can be applied to intraday and tick charts. On daily and higher bars, reported volume remains the input so the formula stays consistent across timeframes.
One signing decision for every plot
A shared volatility-adjusted signing function is intended to feed the oscillator, the color-coded volume bars, and the example strategy so every plot uses the same plus-minus-or-flat volume decision.
Volume bars can be colored from the same +1, -1, or 0 signing factor. A separate alert can fire when volume crosses a stated percentage above its moving average, separating participation color from a volume-expansion warning.
Treat the breakout as a test that can fail
A breakout is a price move through a recent range that is treated as a hypothesis only when a volume-price filter agrees that participation, not just price, has changed.
One stated alert condition looks for the oscillator between -20 and 10, above its exponential average, and with a sufficiently steep linear-regression angle. That combination is treated as a candidate breakout confirmation rather than a standalone entry rule.
Example strategy inputs pair an oscillator entry band and a minimum oscillator regression angle with a price-slope band and optional time-based exit. A breakout hypothesis can be rejected if either the volume-price filter or the price path fails its constructed test.
Editorial: the useful product is the falsifiable checklist. If the signed-volume filter or the price-path band fails, the breakout hypothesis is rejected.
All readings on this track · 61 readings
- 1988Cumulative volume trend and 200-session polarity
- 1988Three clocks when cumulative volume led price
- 1988Payoff index checkpoints for open interest and divergence
- 1988Relative strength, stochastics, and on-balance volume as a turning-point stack
- 1988Signing volume by open interest change
- 1988Case study: weekly on-balance volume with trendlines and a 21-period average
- 1988Combining weekly and daily MACD divergences with on-balance volume
- 1988Restoring the original tests for market breadth, on-balance volume, and trendlines
- 1989Evaluating volume-weighted breadth extremes
- 1989Demand oscillator construction with a momentum overlay
- 1989Constructing a volume percentage ratio from advance-decline flow
- 1990Constructing net positive volume as On-balance volume
- 1990Buying-share scale with on-balance volume
- 1990Friday-filtered on-balance confirmation lines
- 1991Constructing rate-market volume breadth from on-balance volume
- 1991Building a breadth composite from on-balance volume breakouts
- 1992Constructing a rate-complex volume-breadth index
- 1992Constructing a breadth index from on-balance volume
- 1992Constructing signed market thrust from issue volume
- 1992Constructing indicator phase across averages, volume and bands
- 1993Force on-balance volume to agree with itself at slower horizons
- 1993Three transforms of market thrust from breadth and volume
- 1994Constructing a tick-line momentum oscillator
- 1994Constructing a smoothed on-balance tick momentum oscillator
- 1994Histogram confirmation and a second-series veto for MACD-family alerts
- 1994Constructing a 40-period envelope on on-balance volume
- 1996Constructing a matched percent-B volume disparity
- 1997Constructing calendar regime overlays and volume-weighted rules
- 1997Constructing market thrust from breadth and volume
- 1997Constructing on-balance volume as a signed running total
- 1997A three-layer construction for a signed volume-force oscillator
- 1997Constructing a range-sum volume-force oscillator
- 1999On-balance volume confirmation, price-indicator divergence, and bounded exits
- 2000A daily long-only confirmation stack on the tether line
- 2000A three-filter tether and volume trend system
- 2003Constructing finite volume elements as a finite-period money-flow filter
- 2003Constructing on-balance volume from signed session volume
- 2003On-balance volume as a market-breadth participation ledger
- 2003Construct a volatility-adjusted on-balance volume filter before confirming a breakout
- 2004Opening and midday ranges as an on-balance-volume breakout case
- 2004Constructing a volatility-gated volume-flow measure
- 2004Constructing a volume-flow series from on-balance volume
- 2004Volume-flow indicator construction from on-balance volume
- 2004Volume-flow slope divergence, then separate on-balance-volume and crossover rules
- 2004Volume flow and band construction as one inspectable problem
- 2004Auditing advance-decline confirmation for scale, horizon, and composition
- 2005Bounded market breadth from the Arms index to BRIN
- 2006Overnight-hold entry and exit construction
- 2007Evaluating Volume-price confirmation versus On-balance volume and MACD
- 2009Volume confirmation versus a price advance
- 2010Typeahead retrieval of a moving average, on-balance volume, and a stochastic oscillator
- 2010Modified volume-price trend and log-price scale alignment
- 2010Constructing liquidity accelerometers from advance-decline averages
- 2012Failed short cycles as breadth and volume tests
- 2016Earnings straddles, implied volatility, and money-flow filters
- 2017A volume residual filter and a price projection matrix
- 2019Volume-volatility parabola and signed-volume momentum
- 2019Separating on-balance volume into breadth and volume
- 2020Constructing the obvm signal line
- 2020Constructing smoothed on-balance volume with a signal line
- 2020Keep neutrality as a first-class input in three-state market data