Skip to main content
Track Dow Theory
16 / 29
Search the archiveLibrary
Library

2001issue C121-3

Bear-market confirmation via prior correction troughs

A 25 to 35 percent drop from a peak is only a percentage-bear threshold. Bear-market confirmation still waits on a downside support break of the last-bull-market correction, so a fast selloff is not treated as a completed regime change until prior-trough support fails.

  • Bear-market confirmation is a major decline that falls below the trough of the previous major bull-market correction, not a percentage label on its own.
  • The S&P Transportation Index reached the 25 to 35 percent percentage-bear threshold in early fall 1999, then broke its 1998 last-bull-market correction only in December 1999.
  • Related-average confirmation is used when two troughs compete: the transports confirmed the larger 1998 S&P 500 correction and did not confirm the smaller 1999 one.
  • If the 1998 S&P correction low near 972 is the operative prior-trough support, a later low of 1092 stayed about 10 percent above that trough and above both the median-decline marker and the extreme-decline marker.
Entries in this reading3 entries
Current trackDow Theory29 readingsSupport and resistance170 readingsBreakout confirmation172 readings

What counts as bear-market confirmation

In this framework, a bear-market confirmation is a major decline that falls below the trough of the previous major bull-market correction. That last-bull-market correction is the final significant pullback before a bull-market peak, later used as the reference trough.

Prior correction troughs are treated as prior-trough support. A break of that support during an already steep decline is a downside support break and is read as a completed move into bearish territory.

A 25 percent to 35 percent drop from a peak is commonly used as a percentage-bear threshold to label a bear market. That label can be applied without a lower low versus the last-bull-market correction.

How the transports confirmed

The S&P Transportation Index peaked at 835 in spring 1999 after a deep correction from early summer 1998 through year-end. That 1998 low later served as the last-bull-market correction reference trough.

The transports reached the 25 percent to 35 percent band in early fall 1999 without yet making a lower low versus the 1998 correction trough. After a brief rally, the index resumed lower and broke that last-bull-market correction low in December 1999, then fell about another 10 percent before a spring 2000 rebound.

In the transport case, a low formed about one month after the confirmation break and that level was not successfully retested for eight months.

Two candidate troughs on the S&P 500

The S&P 500 peaked near 1550 in spring 2000, leaving two candidate last-bull-market corrections: a larger 1998 decline confirmed by the transports and a smaller 1999 decline that was not. Related-average confirmation is the check that a related average validates the same rally or breakdown before a candidate trough is accepted.

If the smaller 1999 S&P correction is treated as the last-bull-market correction trough, confirmation sits near 1247 at year-end 2000, after which the index declined about another 12 percent.

If the 1998 S&P correction low near 972 is the operative long-term prior-trough support, a later low of 1092 remained about 10 percent above that trough. The index was still above both a 30 percent median-decline marker and a 47 percent extreme-decline marker.

S&P 500 versus two candidate bull-market correction troughs

A trader should see two supports the source marked on the S&P 500: the late-1998 washout near 975 and the late-1999 dip near 1,250. By the final window print of 1,162 the nearer shelf has already given way while the deeper 1998 floor has not, so Dow-style bear confirmation still depends on which trough is treated as the last bull-market correction. Swing points were read from the published MetaStock plot against the 50-point scale; they are approximate.
A trader should see two supports the source marked on the S&P 500: the late-1998 washout near 975 and the late-1999 dip near 1,250. By the final window print of 1,162 the nearer shelf has already given way while the deeper 1998 floor has not, so Dow-style bear confirmation still depends on which trough is treated as the last bull-market correction. Swing points were read from the published MetaStock plot against the 50-point scale; they are approximate.S&P 500 Index · Daily · 1996-11-01T00:00:00.000Z to 2001-10-31T00:00:00.000Z

Digitized from the raster against the printed 600–1600 scale (50-point grid). Placement error is about ±10 index points. The last print, 1,161.97, is taken from the chart-window header. The two horizontals are the support lines drawn on the source chart, not calculated retracements.

Educational research material, not investment advice. Historical source context does not establish present-day performance.
16 of 29 in the Dow Theory track
20021-3 pp.Next on Dow TheoryConstructing a Dow line before breakout confirmationA Dow line is constructed as a multi-week to multi-month interval in which price neither advances nor declines by a significant amount, often tested as a 5 percent line-range-band.
All readings on this track · 29 readings
  1. 1982A bounded-risk entry separates a forecast from a trend
  2. 1984Critiquing reward bias, single-scale charts, and exact-turn forecasts
  3. 1990Constructing dual-average primary-trend confirmation
  4. 1991Two-average confirmation before a primary reversal call
  5. 1991Delayed confirmation is not Dow Theory divergence
  6. 1991Confirmation delay and breadth divergence in a two-average case
  7. 1992Utilities as a rate-regime lead for equities
  8. 1992Critiquing unconfirmed Dow rallies with volume
  9. 1993When Dow Theory signals fail after the decision-makers change
  10. 1994Market life expectancy as a risk filter
  11. 1994Score industrial and transport sync before calling an intermediate-trend signal
  12. 1997A 1995 industrial-average breakout mapped from component trends
  13. 1998Confirm Dow trends with Market breadth and Head and shoulders
  14. 1999Confirming an equity idea with rate, commodity, and index spreads
  15. 2001Why trend, range, and Dow rules need separate tests
  16. 2001Bear-market confirmation via prior correction troughs
  17. 2002Constructing a Dow line before breakout confirmation
  18. 2002Two-average confirmation as a swing-by-swing classroom drill
  19. 2002Withhold the hypothesis until the second average confirms: a 2001 case
  20. 2002A primary-bear case study in cycle speed, Dow theory, and pattern legs
  21. 2003Four index proxies as a bear-regime dashboard
  22. 2004Dual-average confirmation at shared prior highs
  23. 2004Confirmation as the second clock on a trend break
  24. 2004The confirmation-reaction planning window after a joint break
  25. 2005Dow confirmation as a two-average trend test
  26. 2008Related-average confirmation lag after a correction
  27. 2008Intermediate confirmation outranks secular phasing
  28. 2012Align swings to nested energy regimes
  29. 2016From nonconfirmation to a bearish primary trend change
By fieldTrend and channels181 readingsBy year200176 readings
All 29 readings tagged Dow Theory
Also on Dow Theory5 readings
1990Constructing dual-average primary-trend confirmation1994Score industrial and transport sync before calling an intermediate-trend signal2002Constructing a Dow line before breakout confirmation2004Dual-average confirmation at shared prior highs1982A bounded-risk entry separates a forecast from a trend