Skip to main content
Track Order routing
25 / 30
Library

2017issue C1159

Brokerage choice as an execution-speed and commission filter

Treat firm selection as a pre-trade execution filter. Confirm the firm can take the instrument, then score commission and fill speed as implementation cost, and keep research extras or click popularity secondary to order routing.

  • The first executable-order filter is whether the firm handles the specific instrument the trader intends to trade.
  • Commission and execution speed belong with market access in the implementation-cost score, not as a later separate check.
  • Discount brokerage is an online, self-directed channel; full-service brokerage means sitting with a professional for advice, and many full-service houses also offer a discount channel.
  • A frequently viewed brokerage list is a click-count ordering, not an editorial quality ranking.
Entries in this reading2 entries

Brokerage choice as a pre-trade filter

Traders comparing firms are told to weigh execution speed and commission levels together with tools, real-time data, market access, account minimums, and support. TradersWeek editorial reading: treat that comparison as a design step that happens before an order is sent, not as a tour of extras.

Execution speed is how quickly a submitted order can be completed once it leaves the trader. Commission is the explicit fee charged to complete a trade, and it is one visible part of implementation cost. Implementation cost is the combined effect of commissions, speed, access limits, and related frictions on the completed order.

Start with an executable instrument

The first executable-order filter is whether the firm handles the specific instrument the trader intends to trade.

Order routing is the path an order takes through a firm's market access before it can become a fill. TradersWeek editorial reading: if the firm cannot take the intended instrument, later questions about fees, tools, or support do not produce an executable order, and the routing path fails before commission is scored.

Score commission and fill speed together

Once the instrument is available, traders comparing firms are told to weigh execution speed and commission levels together with tools, real-time data, market access, account minimums, and support. TradersWeek editorial reading: put commission schedules and fill speed in the same implementation-cost score, then treat the remaining items as secondary checks rather than as substitutes for a workable fill path.

Service channel is not the same as research value

Discount brokerage is an online, self-directed channel that sends orders without professional advice. Full-service brokerage is a relationship in which the trader sits with a professional for advice rather than placing orders independently online. Many full-service houses also offer a discount channel.

Widely available company information online is presented as reducing the incremental value of generic retail brokerage research. In futures and other less-studied commercial markets, a firm's market statistics, hedging-activity reports, and similar commercial information can still matter for decisions.

TradersWeek editorial reading: generic research extras should not outrank order routing when the firm already has a usable discount or full-service channel.

Ask about clearing after cost and access

After cost and access questions, traders are told to ask about clearing operations and, for equities, Securities Investor Protection Corp. coverage. Clearing is the post-trade operations and counterparties that settle trades and hold customer funds. Securities Investor Protection Corp. coverage is equity-account protection traders are told to ask about when checking the safety of balances.

Educational research material, not investment advice. Historical source context does not establish present-day performance.
25 of 30 in the Order routing track
201859-59 pp.Next on Order routingRouting equivalent contracts across competing venuesSimilar contracts can be listed on more than one exchange, so contract selection includes comparing those alternatives before an order is sent.
All readings on this track · 30 readings
  1. 1988Why instant basket routing overwhelms specialist liquidity
  2. 2004Retail forex tickets as implementation-cost contracts
  3. 2005A two-gate liquidity filter for futures order routing
  4. 2006Manual after-hours routing and open-outcry fill risk
  5. 2010A futures brokerage quote is an execution specification
  6. 2011Smart order routing, maker-taker, and midpoint execution costs
  7. 2012Compare equivalent listings before routing
  8. 2012Rebate-aware routing and execution cost
  9. 2012Platform routing, fees, and server-side stops
  10. 2013Compare equivalent listings, then route the order
  11. 2013Confirm routing, margin, and fill cost before a live forex order
  12. 2013Brokerage choice as an execution-cost and routing filter
  13. 2014Order routing, pass-through rebates, and liquidity choice
  14. 2014Comparing exchange venues before routing the order
  15. 2014Selecting a futures broker as an execution-architecture problem
  16. 2014Commission shopping is the wrong first filter for a futures order
  17. 2015Routing orders when equivalent products trade on multiple venues
  18. 2015Forex venue checks for speed, margin, and implementation cost
  19. 2015Backup venues and symbol splits in futures routing
  20. 2016Route orders across competing exchange venues
  21. 2016Filter exchange venues before routing orders
  22. 2017Venue choice as an order-routing filter
  23. 2017Venue routing for equivalent listed contracts
  24. 2017Forex broker checks for fill speed, quote honor, and margin
  25. 2017Brokerage choice as an execution-speed and commission filter
  26. 2018Routing equivalent contracts across competing venues
  27. 2018Forex venue selection by fill speed, margin terms, and price honor
  28. 2019Forex execution filters for routing, cost, and liquidity
  29. 2020Routing equivalent listings across competing exchanges
  30. 2020Brokerage filters for routing, commissions, and liquidity
All 65 readings tagged Order routing
Also on Order routing5 readings