2013issue C0273
Compare equivalent listings, then route the order
Economically similar products can be listed on more than one venue. Compare those equivalent names first, then send the live order only if the broker can reach the chosen book so fees, fill records, and investor protections actually attach to the execution.
- Economically similar products can be listed on more than one venue, so a trader can compare equivalent names instead of treating a single exchange as the only executable market.
- Venues are distinguished by product, activity, speed, pricing, and investor protections, not only by national borders or a physical trading floor.
- A preferred venue is useful only if the broker can actually send the order to that book.
- Extensive trade records are presented as a practical venue check because they speed dispute resolution after a fill.
One idea, more than one book
Economically similar products can be listed on more than one venue, so a trader can compare equivalent names instead of treating a single exchange as the only executable market.
An equivalentListing is a contract or cash product that can stand in for a similar listing on another exchange. Venues are distinguished by product, activity, speed, pricing, and investor protections, not only by national borders or a physical trading floor.
Contract selection comes first
The first clock is contractSelection: choosing among competing listed names using product design, activity, and how the name sits in a broader book.
Wider venue choice is described as putting downward pressure on transaction costs and ending exclusive control of a product by one exchange.
Route only if the broker can reach the book
The second clock is venueRouting: sending an executable order to a chosen matching engine instead of accepting a default book. A preferred venue is useful only if the broker can actually send the order to that book.
implementationCost is the spread, fees, and fill quality paid to turn an idea into a live position.
Keep the fill record as a venue check
tradeDocumentation is the timestamped record of orders, fills, and market events used if a fill is later disputed. Extensive trade records are presented as a practical venue check because they speed dispute resolution after a fill.
All readings on this track · 30 readings
- 1988Why instant basket routing overwhelms specialist liquidity
- 2004Retail forex tickets as implementation-cost contracts
- 2005A two-gate liquidity filter for futures order routing
- 2006Manual after-hours routing and open-outcry fill risk
- 2010A futures brokerage quote is an execution specification
- 2011Smart order routing, maker-taker, and midpoint execution costs
- 2012Compare equivalent listings before routing
- 2012Rebate-aware routing and execution cost
- 2012Platform routing, fees, and server-side stops
- 2013Compare equivalent listings, then route the order
- 2013Confirm routing, margin, and fill cost before a live forex order
- 2013Brokerage choice as an execution-cost and routing filter
- 2014Order routing, pass-through rebates, and liquidity choice
- 2014Comparing exchange venues before routing the order
- 2014Selecting a futures broker as an execution-architecture problem
- 2014Commission shopping is the wrong first filter for a futures order
- 2015Routing orders when equivalent products trade on multiple venues
- 2015Forex venue checks for speed, margin, and implementation cost
- 2015Backup venues and symbol splits in futures routing
- 2016Route orders across competing exchange venues
- 2016Filter exchange venues before routing orders
- 2017Venue choice as an order-routing filter
- 2017Venue routing for equivalent listed contracts
- 2017Forex broker checks for fill speed, quote honor, and margin
- 2017Brokerage choice as an execution-speed and commission filter
- 2018Routing equivalent contracts across competing venues
- 2018Forex venue selection by fill speed, margin terms, and price honor
- 2019Forex execution filters for routing, cost, and liquidity
- 2020Routing equivalent listings across competing exchanges
- 2020Brokerage filters for routing, commissions, and liquidity