Skip to main content
Track Risk-reward ratio
26 / 27
Search the archiveLibrary
Library

2016issue C086

Pre-trade risk-reward versus instinctive exits

A calculated risk is one whose size has been quantified before the trade is placed. Instinct can create a false sense that the loss is already known. The archive presents a risk-reward ratio as a bound to accept before entry, then keep throughout the position.

  • Calculated risk and careless risk are separated by whether the loss size is quantified before the trade is placed.
  • An instinctive exit can make the loss feel known even when it has not been measured, and it can reopen emotional decisions once price moves.
  • A risk-reward ratio compares bounded loss to expected gain before entry so the exposure decision stays limited.
  • Even-odds forecasts with later if-up and if-down exits are treated as insufficient; analysis needs better than even directional odds, and being wrong belongs in the pre-trade calculation.
Entries in this reading1 entry
Current trackRisk-reward ratio78 readings

Calculated risk is measured before entry

A calculated risk is distinguished from a careless risk by whether the size of the risk has been quantified before the trade is placed. Calculated-risk exposure has been measured in size before entry, so the loss is known rather than guessed. Careless-risk exposure is taken without quantifying how large a loss, stop distance, or position can become.

Relying on instinct can create a false sense that risk is already known, even when the loss has not been measured. An instinctive-exit plan is a decision to leave only after price reaches a remembered level. That plan can reopen emotional decisions about the loss after the position is already on.

Even-odds forecasts are not a bound

An even-odds-forecast treats direction as equally likely either way, then pairs that guess with a later exit rule instead of a quantified bound. Conditional if-up and if-down plans that rest only on even directional odds are treated as insufficient. Better than 50% odds from analysis are required.

Expected move size, expected gain, and the point at which a loss is taken are framed as questions that require some form of forecast.

Accept the risk-reward bound first

A quantitative alternative is presented as knowing the amount at risk, respecting that bound, and only then entering the trade. A risk-reward-ratio is a pre-entry comparison of bounded loss to expected gain, used to keep a loss or exposure decision limited before and during the trade.

The starting point of a risk-management approach is described as seeking a favorable outcome while keeping risk limited. A limited-risk-setup is a candidate chosen because the expected outcome is favorable while the downside is kept bounded. The possibility of being wrong is treated as a factor that must be included in the pre-trade calculation rather than ignored.

Tools still need a quantified bound

Indicators, chart patterns, and hedges are listed as tools that may aid opportunity selection only if risk and reward are quantified before entry.

Educational research material, not investment advice. Historical source context does not establish present-day performance.
26 of 27 in the Risk-reward ratio track
202016-19 pp.Next on Risk-reward ratioBounding a short-dated option spread with a stop, a gap remainder, and a credit exitIn the worked example, a stop at 73.50 implied a loss of roughly 62 if hit immediately and roughly 19 if hit on expiration day.
All readings on this track · 27 readings
  1. 1987Precommit the stop and require a surplus payoff
  2. 1987When open losses overwrite precommitted exit rules
  3. 1991Ranking month-end holds with risk-reward and stops
  4. 1994Evaluating percentage profit exits on trend-following averages
  5. 2001Construct reward to risk before entry
  6. 2003A pre-trade readiness checklist for entry, abstention, and risk
  7. 2003Evaluating out-of-the-money strikes with saddle premiums and implied volatility
  8. 2004A critique of one-procedure trading decisions
  9. 2004Mechanical stops leak intent and misprice losses
  10. 2004Implied-volatility premium on rate indexes
  11. 2006Keep the stop that authorized the entry
  12. 2006Bound the loss with a risk-to-reward filter before entry
  13. 2007Audit the operator before abandoning a system
  14. 2007Failed-break slingshot reversal rules
  15. 2007A system-management template that sets the stop and the required reward before entry
  16. 2007Construct a pre-trade style envelope for entries and skips
  17. 2008Systems that skip the three decision gates
  18. 2010Four-gate veto before trend entries
  19. 2012Construct a trading plan as one written procedure
  20. 2012Forex stops and reward targets by quote increment
  21. 2013The average directional index as a lookback cluster and a risk-reward bound
  22. 2014A three-step worksheet for VIX futures tick value and low-vol risk-reward
  23. 2014Binary option premia, fees, and pre-expiry risk-reward
  24. 2015Selling far out-of-the-money commodity option premium as a forgiving timing case
  25. 2016Prepaid option spreads that bound range-day risk and reward
  26. 2016Pre-trade risk-reward versus instinctive exits
  27. 2020Bounding a short-dated option spread with a stop, a gap remainder, and a credit exit
By fieldStops and loss limits76 readingsBy year2016134 readings
All 78 readings tagged Risk-reward ratio
Also on Risk-reward ratio5 readings
1987Precommit the stop and require a surplus payoff1987When open losses overwrite precommitted exit rules1991After a Wyckoff bias, rank leftover cause and keep three-to-one stops1991Ranking month-end holds with risk-reward and stops1992Filter size by expected value and ruin