Skip to main content
Track Commitment of Traders
6 / 20
Search the archiveLibrary
Library

1996issue C101-5

Pork belly Commitment of Traders signals depend on the seasonal window

In the historical pork-belly study, whether a trader class was a useful directional guide or a fade depended on the seasonal window rather than on a single all-year rule.

  • Whether a trader class was a useful directional guide or a fade depended on the seasonal window rather than on a single all-year rule.
  • Commercial-hedger extremes on a 12-period Commitment of Traders index, long above 90 and short below 10, produced 58 February pork-belly trades, with 10- and 15-day win rates of 64 percent and chi-square values of 3.88.
  • An all-year large-speculator rule was weaker than an August-only rule, and November was treated as a fade window because large speculators were often wrong on direction.
  • Small-speculator extremes were presented as the strongest contrary setup, consistent with late-crowd positioning at turning points in a highly speculative meat market.
Entries in this reading3 entries
Current trackCommitment of Traders21 readingsContrarian strategy26 readingsSeasonal analysis54 readings

A seasonal reading, not a single rule

In the historical pork-belly study, whether a trader class was a useful directional guide or a fade depended on the seasonal window rather than on a single all-year rule.

The historical workflow combined Commitment of Traders positioning with Seasonal analysis of the calendar window, and it used a Contrarian strategy when a class was treated as a fade rather than a follow.

Commercial hedgers in February

Commercial-hedger extremes on a 12-period Commitment of Traders index, long above 90 and short below 10, produced 58 February pork-belly trades, with 10- and 15-day win rates of 64 percent and chi-square values of 3.88.

Large speculators by month

A more liberal all-year large-speculator rule, long above 60 and short below 40, generated 99 trades and weaker results, with a 10-day win rate of 54 percent and a chi-square of 0.36.

Restricting large-speculator signals to August, long above 80 and short below 20, reduced the sample to 7 trades and raised the 15-day win rate to 100 percent with a chi-square of 5.14.

In November, large speculators were often wrong on direction, so the study treated that month as a fade window rather than a follow window.

Small speculators as a contrary setup

Small-speculator extremes were presented as the strongest contrary setup, consistent with late-crowd positioning at turning points in a highly speculative meat market.

February 1996 pork-belly futures, August 1995 through expiration

Approximate closes read from the ChartBook candlesticks for the February 1996 pork-belly contract. A trader using Barrie’s August large-speculator rule would have been buying in the low 50s; the later November slide and January gap show why he treated that month as a fade instead of a follow.
Approximate closes read from the ChartBook candlesticks for the February 1996 pork-belly contract. A trader using Barrie’s August large-speculator rule would have been buying in the low 50s; the later November slide and January gap show why he treated that month as a fade instead of a follow.February 1996 pork bellies · Daily · 1995-08-04T00:00:00.000Z to 1996-02-29T00:00:00.000Z

Closes were read off the daily candlestick raster to the nearest half-cent against a two-cent grid. The 29 February 1996 value of 62.65 is the printed quote, not a bar reading. The window begins in early August, later than the June start of Barrie’s study.

How a holding period was judged

The study judged a holding period statistically notable when chi-square was at least 3.86, using the open after the Commitment of Traders release versus later settlement.

Educational research material, not investment advice. Historical source context does not establish present-day performance.
6 of 20 in the Commitment of Traders track
20021-3 pp.Next on Commitment of TradersConstructing regime context from trader commitment netsPublic commitment reports place identified accounts in a commercial class, a noncommercial class, or leftover nonreportable positions, and one entity is not both commercial and noncommercial in the same commodity.
All readings on this track · 20 readings
  1. 1990Constructing a COT index from the commercial-speculative spread
  2. 1990Crowded price rules need abstention and a regime overlay
  3. 1991Advisor consensus fails as weekly contrarian timing
  4. 1996When speculative flows decouple bonds from stocks
  5. 1996Score each trader class against itself, then slice by month
  6. 1996Pork belly Commitment of Traders signals depend on the seasonal window
  7. 2002Constructing regime context from trader commitment nets
  8. 2002Trader net positions as regime context for chart setups
  9. 2003Three states for a daily futures advisor consensus
  10. 2005Commitment of Traders open-interest extremes as regime filters
  11. 2005Commitment of Traders participant imbalance as regime context for commodity position trades
  12. 2006Housing slowdown as a cross-market regime lesson
  13. 2007Evaluate an index stance as a spread between trader books
  14. 2011Constructing weekly participant positioning ledgers
  15. 2012Commitment of Traders as crowded-book context, not a copy signal
  16. 2014When Commitment of Traders smart money fails as an intermarket regime filter
  17. 2014Constructing Commitment of Traders regime context when commercial hedgers fail
  18. 2015Leave a yen bottom unconfirmed until gold and positioning agree
  19. 2016Stacking volume, open interest, and trader books around expiration
  20. 2025Post-crash cash and regime-aware watchlists
By fieldSeasonality and regimes93 readingsBy year199680 readings
All 21 readings tagged Commitment of Traders
Also on Commitment of Traders5 readings
1991Advisor consensus fails as weekly contrarian timing2003Three states for a daily futures advisor consensus2007Evaluate an index stance as a spread between trader books2012Commitment of Traders as crowded-book context, not a copy signal2014Constructing Commitment of Traders regime context when commercial hedgers fail