2002issue C011-2
Market-order routing across linked venues
Shares listed on one primary-listing can also quote on regional exchanges and electronic communication networks. A market-order chooses which of those books will fill it, the primary-listing is the reference when the books disagree, and paper-trading cannot show how live size changes available prices.
- Order-routing is the choice of which listing venue, regional book, or electronic communication network receives a live order.
- The same market-order size sent to more than one book can fill at different prices; when venues disagree, the primary-listing quote is the reference.
- The tape and give-up labels do not disclose a firm’s own completed orders or useful net positioning, so they are not a method to copy.
- Paper-trading does not send size into the book and cannot show how a live order changes available prices.
A listing is a destination problem
Shares of a company listed on one primary-listing can also trade on regional exchanges and electronic communication networks, sometimes at different displayed bids. Order-routing is the choice of which listing venue, regional book, or electronic communication network will receive a live order.
A market-order is an instruction to trade immediately at the price the chosen destination will give, which can differ if the same size is sent to more than one book. Sending the same sale as a market-order to several venues can result in several different fill prices.
The primary-listing as reference
Venues displaying the same listing are electronically linked, which limits how lasting a cross-venue price gap can be. When venues disagree, the listing or primary-market price is the reference to rely on. The primary-listing is the exchange where the company is officially listed and whose quote is that reference.
Equity market value is outstanding share count times the current price and does not depend on which exchange last traded the shares.
What the tape and give-up leave out
Exchanges do not publish a daily recap of which members or market makers bought and sold, and such a recap would still mix customer-agency flow with proprietary activity.
The tape is the public record of printed fills, which may omit a firm’s own completed orders. Tape prints of public fills do not necessarily disclose a firm’s own filled orders.
A give-up is a member-firm identifier attached to a handled trade, which does not by itself reveal that firm’s inventory or intent. Member give-up identifiers can be obtained, but those labels alone do not reveal useful net positioning.
Two traders can take different live actions in the same situation, so tracking others in order to copy their methods is not a workable approach.
Paper-trading and live size
Actual orders change the market; a paper-trading simulation does not produce that feedback. Paper-trading is a simulation of entries and exits that does not send size into the book and therefore cannot show how a live order changes available prices.
All readings on this track · 26 readings
- 1995Canceled prints versus executable fills
- 1999How order routing changes market and limit fills
- 2000Direct access, intelligent order routing, and visible book depth
- 2001Retail routing and market versus limit fills
- 2001Stop triggers and opening-only short market orders
- 2002Market-order routing across linked venues
- 2002Market-order routing, internalization, and displayed size
- 2004Direct access order routing after the display rules
- 2004Listed-stock limit envelopes versus market-order routing
- 2005Closing option spreads with limit or market orders
- 2005Contingent routing as a pre-trade futures contract
- 2007Constructing executable futures orders with market, limit, and fill or kill
- 2008Bid-ask spreads, routing paths, and order choice
- 2008Retail market buys hit the ask
- 2008Limit versus market orders for a commodity option-spread
- 2011A pre-trade checklist before market or limit orders
- 2013Retail market orders and the displayed queue they never join
- 2013Option stop orders, wide spreads and forced market exits
- 2014Opening range breakout with weekday ratings, abstention and exits
- 2014Constructing forex orders from session liquidity
- 2015Order-type and routing scripts for faster execution
- 2015Market, limit, and routing choices inside the order life cycle
- 2015Handheld futures tickets as a second execution venue
- 2017Screen execution starts from the live bid and ask
- 2017Electronic stop-loss orders and protected price bands
- 2020Market-order slippage on split-adjusted stock prices