2017issue C1021
Electronic stop-loss orders and protected price bands
After electronic matching replaced open-outcry handling, a triggered stop-loss was treated as a market order. Later venue protections confined a filled stop to an exchange-defined range around the quote at trigger time, while an opposite-side limit order was still required to complete the trade.
- A stop-loss order is a resting instruction that becomes executable only after the market reaches a stated trigger price.
- Once electronic matching replaced open-outcry handling, a triggered stop-loss was treated as a market order and no longer received discretionary fill management from a floor broker.
- A triggered buy-stop still fills only if matching software finds a resting sell-limit willing to take the other side. Reaching the stop price does not complete the trade by itself.
- If a protected stop-loss is filled, the fill is constrained to an exchange-defined reasonable-price range that varies by market and is updated as conditions change.
What a stop-loss order waits for
A stop-loss order is a resting instruction that becomes executable only after the market reaches a stated trigger price. The trigger is the instant the stated stop price becomes part of the quoted market and the order is released for matching.
When the trigger became a market order
Once electronic matching replaced open-outcry handling, a triggered stop-loss was treated as a market order and no longer received discretionary fill management from a floor broker. A market order is an instruction to trade immediately against the next available opposite-side interest, with no trader-chosen limit on the print.
Electronic futures venues later added price protections so a triggered stop-loss would not be filled at extreme unintended prices the way an unconstrained market order could.
The other side of the book
A triggered buy-stop still fills only if matching software finds a resting sell-limit willing to take the other side. Reaching the stop price does not complete the trade by itself. A limit order is a resting bid or offer that names the worst acceptable price and supplies the other side of a triggered stop.
Slippage and the protected price band
Scheduled news can move grain futures 20 to 30 cents almost instantly and crude oil by a dollar or two, conditions in which a working stop-loss is not guaranteed to exit at the stated stop price. Slippage is the gap between the intended stop price and the eventual fill when the book is thin or prices jump.
If a protected stop-loss is filled, the fill is constrained to an exchange-defined reasonable-price range that varies by market and is updated as conditions change. That protected range is an exchange-calculated band around the bid and offer at trigger time inside which a filled stop is allowed to print.
For the e-mini S&P, the protection point was 3.00, so a triggered fill could not exceed 3.00 above the best ask or 3.00 below the best bid, a 6.00-point protected price band. The protected price band is the full interval spanning the buy-side and sell-side protection points around the quote at the moment of trigger.
Under ordinary trading conditions those price protections typically remain unused and unnoticed.
All readings on this track · 26 readings
- 1995Canceled prints versus executable fills
- 1999How order routing changes market and limit fills
- 2000Direct access, intelligent order routing, and visible book depth
- 2001Retail routing and market versus limit fills
- 2001Stop triggers and opening-only short market orders
- 2002Market-order routing across linked venues
- 2002Market-order routing, internalization, and displayed size
- 2004Direct access order routing after the display rules
- 2004Listed-stock limit envelopes versus market-order routing
- 2005Closing option spreads with limit or market orders
- 2005Contingent routing as a pre-trade futures contract
- 2007Constructing executable futures orders with market, limit, and fill or kill
- 2008Bid-ask spreads, routing paths, and order choice
- 2008Retail market buys hit the ask
- 2008Limit versus market orders for a commodity option-spread
- 2011A pre-trade checklist before market or limit orders
- 2013Retail market orders and the displayed queue they never join
- 2013Option stop orders, wide spreads and forced market exits
- 2014Opening range breakout with weekday ratings, abstention and exits
- 2014Constructing forex orders from session liquidity
- 2015Order-type and routing scripts for faster execution
- 2015Market, limit, and routing choices inside the order life cycle
- 2015Handheld futures tickets as a second execution venue
- 2017Screen execution starts from the live bid and ask
- 2017Electronic stop-loss orders and protected price bands
- 2020Market-order slippage on split-adjusted stock prices