2018issue C0134-38

Why-first stories leak the tape test for entry, exit and abstention

A classroom workflow uses one visual tape reading to take a name, avoid a name, or stand aside. TradersWeek treats a why-first causal story as a leak in that system, because entry, exit and standing aside then stop being the same checkable signal.

A classroom chart drill uses one visual direction call of up, sideways, or down to decide both which names to take and which names to avoid.
The operating rule is to act on what price and volume are doing, not on a story about why they are doing it.
Price and volume are treated as public, hard-to-conceal inputs, so the same tape can check entry, exit, and standing aside.
TradersWeek editorial reading: a why-first causal story is a leak because it is not the same checkable signal.

Entries in this reading1 entry

Current trackTrading psychology process376 readings

The classroom tape test

A classroom chart drill uses one visual direction call of up, sideways, or down to decide both which names to take and which names to avoid. Observers of that drill treated mental roadblocks and overthinking, not missing facts, as the main barrier to following the visual test.

Adult continuing-education classes are framed as learners who want a usable market procedure, not a graded course or a product pitch.

The same tape for entry, exit and standing aside

The operating rule is to act on what price and volume are doing, not on a story about why they are doing it. Price and volume are treated as public, hard-to-conceal inputs that record buyers and sellers voting with money, so the same tape can check entry, exit, and standing aside.

A 50/50 thought experiment isolates two equal groups of market-naive people, teaches one group only a visual tape method and the other only a fundamentals method, then has each apply only that method for six months.

A process practiced in stages

A ten-stage sequence is used to compartmentalize a full decision process so each stage can be identified and practiced on its own. The same organized process is meant to serve more than one holding period, from shorter-horizon trading to longer-horizon investing.

Personal execution is transferred in stages. A large remaining share can stay with an outside manager at first, with self-directed control expanding only as the procedure is internalized.

Explaining a live procedure to others is described as a discipline that forces the teacher to follow the same rules they prescribe.

Educational research material, not investment advice. Historical source context does not establish present-day performance.

82 of 89 in the Trading psychology process track

201860-61 pp.Next on Trading psychology processReplace intuition with a testable decision procedureIntuition is an untested, feeling-based prompt and is not decision authority.

All readings on this track · 89 readings

By fieldDecision process416 readings By year2018172 readings

All 376 readings tagged Trading psychology process

Also on Trading psychology process5 readings

1984Critiquing reward bias, single-scale charts, and exact-turn forecasts 1985Treat a shared mechanical printout as a public script 1985Event-class hazards and pre-trade survival checks 1986Fear signals an untested decision process 1986Construct a decision procedure that revises itself