2005issue C081-5

A mid-life payoff chart is a volatility-regime assumption

The Black-Scholes model can make the same combination look early-profitable or still dead money depending on whether implied volatility snaps back to one underlying-linked value or stays sticky. Editorial: that choice matters most when a calendar spread is judged against a short straddle after a near-term volatility shock.

Option pricing formulas take five inputs, and the volatility input is treated as a statistic of daily price variability, not as a trend in the underlying.
A naive Black-Scholes forecast that applies one underlying-linked volatility assumes initially rich options cheapen toward theoretical fair value at every future date before expiration.
Persistent-volatility forecasting carries each option's own current implied volatility forward, so any initial richness remains until time decay near expiration.
Editorial: the same engine can change how a calendar spread looks against a short straddle after a near-term volatility shock, because forcing a jump in near-term implied volatility to persist can hide a later chance that those options cheapen.

Entries in this reading3 entries

Current trackBlack-Scholes Model20 readings Options calendar spread30 readings Implied volatility analysis176 readings

The chart is already a forecast

Option pricing formulas take five inputs, and one of those inputs is volatility. Volatility is presented as a statistic of daily price variability that is independent of any trend in the underlying.

The Black-Scholes model is a closed-form pricing engine that maps contract terms and a volatility input into a theoretical value and into forecasted mid-life payoffs. Theoretical fair value is the model price obtained when that engine is run with a chosen volatility input rather than the price observed in the listed chain.

A short straddle still carries its premium

A short straddle is a combination that sells a put and a call sharing one strike and one expiration. In the theoretical expiration illustration, the short combination was profitable only if the underlying finished inside a limited range.

Shortly after entry, both legs still carry nearly the premiums received, so early profitability is small unless the underlying has already moved a long way.

Mid-life P/L of a short MSFT 25 straddle

Nineteen days after the 5 May 2005 snapshot, the same short September 25 call and put still show a small net credit near the $25.17 spot, not the expiration tent. The black net stays slightly positive between about $23.40 and $26.10, while the short call falls and the short put rises as the underlying moves. Values were read off the Options Laboratory Strategist plot (projected to 24 May 2005, Black-Scholes, vol 0.182), not from a printed table.MSFT · Projected to 24 May 2005 from 5 May 2005 · 2005-05-05T00:00:00.000Z to 2005-05-24T00:00:00.000Z

Digitized from the mid-life screenshot. Axes are $ profit/loss versus underlying price; y-values are approximate to the nearest 5 dollars. The source held volatility at 0.182 with implied vol 0.191 and a 2% rate, so the hump is a sticky-vol Black-Scholes mark, not a guaranteed payoff.

Two rules for implied volatility

Implied volatility is the unique volatility input that makes a pricing model reproduce an option's observed market price. A naive Black-Scholes forecast that applies one underlying-linked volatility then assumes initially rich options cheapen toward that model value at every future date before expiration.

Persistent-volatility is a forecasting rule that carries each listed option's current implied volatility forward instead of forcing prices back to a single underlying-linked fair value. Under that rule, any initial richness remains until time decay near expiration.

A calendar spread is judged on a different carry rule

A calendar spread is a same-strike structure that buys a longer-dated option and sells a nearer-dated option. A typical calendar spread buys a longer-dated call and sells a same-strike call that expires sooner.

Longer-dated implied volatility is described as relatively stable, while the short-dated calendar leg is less sensitive to a volatility-input error because it is near expiration, so a persistent-volatility forecast is presented as generally more realistic for that structure.

After a sharp unexpected price move, near-term implied volatilities often jump, and forcing that elevation to persist can hide a later chance that those options cheapen.

Educational research material, not investment advice. Historical source context does not establish present-day performance.

10 of 18 in the Black-Scholes Model track

20051-3 pp.Next on Black-Scholes ModelExotic option payoffs beyond the vanilla premiumTreat the vanilla option premium as an insurer's fee: it is meant to cover both the service of taking risk and payouts on contracts that do not expire worthless.

All readings on this track · 18 readings

By fieldOptions and volatility435 readings By year2005167 readings

All 20 readings tagged Black-Scholes Model

Also on Black-Scholes Model5 readings

2002Calendar income from volatility skew and time stops 2004Calendar construction from exercise style, time budget, and carry 1988Constructing option premiums against a Black-Scholes baseline 1988Critiquing Black-Scholes early exercise on futures options 1990When volatility skews are regimes, not mispricings